Apr 12, 2011 its ok to quote word for word if it perpetuates more belief, but when confronted with an immoral subject like slavery, then it should not be taken literally. Many of which were caused by new inventions that lead to industrialization, the new. Ford douglas and usher linder, a proslavery illinois lawyer whom. Almost 2,000 years after pauls letter, the th chapter of pauls instruction to the romans is still being used to silence, warn and. Proslavery arguments, on the other hand, positively prom. While i agree slavery is an ill moral, the concept of slavery is an economic plus. Nearly every proslavery pamphlet, or article, or speaker made at least some reference to a biblical sanction of slavery. In the decades leading up to the civil war, sectional tensions between north and south manifested themselves in both popular and political discourse. Antiabolition arguments in this period focused on defects in the abolitionist platform, emphasising the illegal, illogical, inhumane, or pro french nature of their aims.
Focusing their argument on the rights of slaveholders to transfer their property in. The pro terengganu faction was defeated in 1800 and long muhammad ruled kelantan with the new title of sultan as sultan muhammad i. How the bible was used to justify slavery, abolitionism cnn. Dec 07, 2012 a favorite proslavery argument blog entry posted on december 7, 2012 by jd thomas slaves are better fed, clothed and treated, and more kindly cared for in old age, than the majority of northern laborers. The proslavery and antislavery americans argued against each other on whether slavery is morally correct and satisfactory or not. He concludes his book with the dubious claim that abolitionists placed their hope. The liberty party, a political action group, held its first national convention, at albany, n. He lived, got married to anne hampton, a woman of mixed black, white, and native american and worked in new york, where is his family stayed. Harper, william, james henry hammond, william gilmore simms on. Choose from 124 different sets of pro slavery argument flashcards on quizlet. Feb 02, 2012 anti slavery arguments were unpopular, even in the north. In 1856, a pro slavery group attacked the town of lawrence, which was founded by abolitionists from massachusetts. How the bible was used to justify slavery, abolitionism.
Harper advanced several philosophical, racial, and economic arguments on behalf of slavery, but his central idea was that slavery anticipates the benefits of civilization and retards the evils of civilization. I mean that the constitution protected slavery and promoted slave ownership. Mps claimed ports wouldnt be able to make money without trade. Some insisted that african americans were childlike people in. Text of the pro slavery argument 1832, by thomas dewthomas roderick dew 18021846 was an economist, professor of law, and president of the college of william and mary. The pro slavery political argument, like the anti slavery argument, was essentially a legal and territorial one. Uncle toms cabin and its role in starting the civil war. In fact, the two movements also championed a form of. Rare book and special collections division, library of congress 3 2. Of course, unlike anti slavery consitutiionalists, pro slavery persons made the argument that the constitution offered firm protections to the institution of slavery.
Proslavery argument by southerners free essay sample. The changing view of frederick douglass national council for the. In the book fitzhugh unapologetically acknowledges that the south is a slave. In reaction to the radical abolitionists, the south defended its society and culture, and began to systematize its proslavery. The apportionment clause, article i, section 2, added threefifths of all other persons. Abolition, antislavery movements, and the rise of the. The defenders of slavery in the south had several arguments that they used to rationalize slavery. The abolitionist movement was the effort to end slavery, led by. The rise of the radical abolitionist movement placed a new emphasis on the moralityor, rather, the immoralityof slavery. However, in the burney treaty of 1826, the treaty acknowledged siamese claims over several northern malay states kedah, kelantan, perlis, terengganu the future unfederated malay states and patani. During an 1855 visit to boston, massachusetts and new haven, connecticut, fitzhugh gave public lectures and engaged in lively debates. Another proslavery argument was that slavery was a natural state of mankind since it has existed throughout history. Defenders claimed britain would lose 60% of its trade.
Slaves, of course, do the work of the plantation, but they also represent a substantial capital investment. He demonstrated that arguments to the effect that slavery was a positive good arose before the rise of abolitionism during the 1830s. A catalogue record for the book is available from the british library. The proslavery argument in the development of the american.
Decrying slavery as barbaric, he criticizes various pro slavery arguments and offers statistics to show how. Calling it a moral depravity1 and a hideous blot, 2 he believed that slavery presented the greatest threat to the survival of the new american nation. Douglass argued that the constitutions rhetoric about liberty. Abolition, antislavery movements, and the rise of the sectional. The constitutions text contains several proslavery clauses. The proslavery lobby put forward a number of arguments to defend the trade and show. In the debate over whether new states and territories should be free or slaveholding, few spoke more passionately than massachusetts senator charles sumner.
But while antebellum americans did not invent biblical pro and antislavery arguments, the debate did enter a new phase after 1831. Argument that the bible was proslavery custom university. Fear, providence and the abolition of the slave trade. Slavery was seen by the northerners as evil because it did not entitle slaves to the rights of a free man. Currie to miss cropper, 23 may 1788, printed in life of james currie, volume ii, appendix. Nor was slavery immoral, for dew saw masters treat their slaves with such benevolence and fairness that the slaves responded with joyful obedience. A vocal slavery advocate, george fitzhughs first publication was a pamphlet titled slavery justified 1849, a text reprinted as an appendix in his 1854 sociology for the south. Its far easier than admitting the truth that a book touted as a moral guide should not condone slavery in the first place.
C defenders of slavery positive social based their arguments on racial doctrines, the view that slavery was a good, and the belief that slavery and states rights were protected by the constitution. With an argument that was as much a critique of industrialism as it was a defense of slavery, southern spokesmen contended that chattel slavery, as it was practiced in the american south, was more humane than the system of wage slavery that prevailed in the industrial north and great britain. In a book by an unknown author the negro and the free born briton. The mobilisation of public opinion against the slave trade and slavery. Even though abolitionism, as a political cause, remained unpopular in the north and south, antislavery literature such as harriet beecher stowe s uncle tom s cabin 1852, solomon northups twelve years a slave 1854, and the autobiographical narrative of the life of frederick douglass 1845 were widely. The kennedy and doyle tragedy, indonesian news bulletin, new delhi, 3 may 1950, box. Sep 08, 2020 pro 2 slavery left african american communities at the mercy of the slave health deficit, which should be addressed with reparations. Health policy research scholar brittney butler, phd, explains, the health effects of slavery and racism in the u. A comparison between the proslavery and antislavery arguments. Even though abolitionism, as a political cause, remained unpopular in the north and south, antislavery literature such as harriet beecher stowes uncle toms cabin 1852, solomon northups twelve years a slave. George fitzhughs proslavery argument was probably the. Harpers assessment of other nations around the world confirmed this point of view.
In the united states, proslavery sentiment arose in the antebellum period as a reaction to the growing antislavery movement in the united states in the late 18th century and early 19th century. Douglas had previously defeated lincoln in the 1858 united states senate election in illinois, known for the lincolndouglas debates. This article discusses the evolution of the methodist church. In this speech, delivered before the senate in 1860 when kansas applied for statehood, sumner makes clear his abolitionist stance. History ch 10 proslavery and antislavery arguments. Jan 12, 2021 oddly this view of the constitution as a pro slavery document was what the fervent hardline apologists for slavery, like senator john c. Slaves, of course, do the work of the plantation, but. Concerned with the new territories, pro slavery political leaders pushed for legislation which would permit slavery in said territories. Mar 14, 2018 modern neoabolitionist historians have taken up the garrisondouglass argument, beginning with paul finkelman, who develops an even longer list of provisions in the constitution which betray a pro slavery biasthe electoral college and the direction that assessment of direct taxes, both of which are calculated by using the three fifths.
A proslavery argument, 1857 a close reading guide from america in class 2 amount of pay, only to abandon them when they cease to be useful. Donald mathews, in his book slavery and methodism, claims that from. The defenders of slavery included economics, history, religion, legality, social good, and even humanitarianism, to further their arguments. Hesseltine, some new aspects of the pro slavery argument, journal of negro historv washington, xxi january, 1936, 115. Stephen arnold douglas april 23, 18 june 3, 1861 was an american politician and lawyer from illinois. First, the transatlantic slave trade would be abolished. Text of the proslavery argument 1832, by thomas dew. Among white americans in lincolns time, opposition to slavery and support for advancing the civil and political rights of black people were far from being one and the same thing. The proslavery argument, as maintained by the most distinguished writers of the southern states by harper, william 17901847, hammond, james henry 18071864 and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. It specifically focuses on the way that pro slavery views were eventually supported by many members of the church, using the bible to support these beliefs.
Defenders of slavery argued that the sudden end to the slave economy would have had a profound and killing economic impact in the south where reliance on slave labor was the foundation of their economy. A proslavery argument, 1857 america in class resources. In this printed version of his 1791 sermon to a local anti slavery group, he notes the progress toward abolition in the north and predicts that through. The religious defense of american slavery before 1830 larry r. Proslavery politics and the slave trade springerlink. Dumas, in her study of the history of the british proslavery movement, draws a distinction between antiabolitionist and proslavery positions. Twelve years a slave is a book which is written by solomon northup. In the southern slave economy, on the other hand, labor is capital.
The th chapter of romans is white supremacy, explained. From the very beginning much of the attack upon slaveholding had always been upon moral grounds. In 1846, matthew estes published a defence of negro slavery, as it exists in the. Proslavery is an ideology that perceives slavery as a positive good or an otherwise morally acceptable institution. Douglass speaks about how slavery corrupted mrs auld, describing how her tender heart became stone. As maintained by the most distinguished writers of the southern states. Rare book and special collections division, library of congress 32. Critics of abolition argued that it contradicted the u. Argument that the bible was proslavery custom university papers. Tise challenged this common belief about proslavery arguments. The pro slavery argument in the development of the american methodist church. As illustrated by some of quotations above, proslavery writers typically appealed to some version of utilitarianism, maintaining that slavery serves a greater social goodthat it tends to promote the public weal thompson and happiness on the whole, parsons, and lest they concede that the freedom of some should be sacrificed for the welfare of others, many of the defenders of slavery maintained that even slaves are better off and happier than then would have been in africa.
If skates were released then they would kill white people as r. These ten persuasive arguments for slavery made by intell. In the south the philosophy and defence of slavery and of a society based on inequalities among its members became the dominating theme. He then asserts, the society didosuccessfully push to make sla.
A brief history of people using romans to justify white. The religious defense of american slavery before 1830. In retaliation, abolitionist john brown organized a raid that killed five pro. Arguments for abortion mimic the arguments for slavery. Learn pro slavery argument with free interactive flashcards. Abolitionists and the constitution constitutional rights foundation. The first national anti slavery convention was held in new york city in 1837, and the following year the second anti slavery convention of american women met in philadelphia. The growing attitudes against the enslavement of black people in the north, which had been reinforced by the content of uncle toms cabin, no doubt helped to secure. A favorite proslavery argument accessible archives inc. The abolition movement sought to end the practice of slavery in the united states. A proslavery argument, 1857 america in class resources for.
Have you ever wondered how chattel slavery was ever accepted and even championed by so many people. His influential pro slavery argument offers theological, historical, and political evidence in a pointbypoint refutation of the anti slavery arguments of his day. In your spiral or as a text entry on canvas, list the main argument for. They did not spring up suddenly in response to the unrelenting attacks of abolitionists. Inspire a love of reading with amazon book box for kids discover delightful childrens books with amazon book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new amazon book box prime customers receive 15% off your first box. Averil mcclelland and adapted by marian maxfield, kent state university. How did proponents of slavery in antebellum america defend it as a positive good. In the antebellum period, pro slavery forces moved from defending slavery as a necessary evil to expounding it as a positive good. One argument was that ending slavery would destroy the economy in the south. However, the southerners countered this statement by d. The argument that the constitution implicitly preserved the. Writing, sentiment and slavery, 17601807 basingstoke. He then asserts, the society didosuccessfully push to make slavery illegal in new.
British people would have to pay lots more money for goods tha. An introduction to political ideas title how successful is the argument against slavery that douglass makes in the narrative, and what if any its implications for society today in this essay i will analyse douglass arguments against slavery, beginning with his argument that slavery is cruel and therefore wrong. Dec 04, 20 the defenders of slavery in the south had several arguments that they used to rationalize slavery. Jeffersons attitudes toward slavery thomas jeffersons. S has transcended generations and laid the foundation of poor health for black families in the u. That is a convenient cop out every believer enjoys. Two great abolitionists, william lloyd garrison and. Biographers praise alexander hamilton for being an abolitionist, but they have. A comparison between the proslavery and antislavery. Pro slavery arguments 1banning slavery would deprive slave owners of their property their slaves 2 african americans were better off enslaved than free because slave owners in the south stated that they cared for them. Zephaniah kingsley is the author of the most popular proslavery tract, selfpublished in 1828 and reprinted three times. Connecticut theologian jonathan edwards, born 1745, echoes benezets use of the golden rule as well as the natural rights arguments of the revolutionary era to justify the abolition of slavery. Arguments for abortion mimic the arguments for slavery before. Garrison and his colleagues condemned slaveholding as sinful, a moral evil to be.
A rhetorical analysis of selected proslavery sermons by. The discussion had begun a generation earlier with the memorable debates in the virginia legislature of 1831. Brycchan carey, british abolitionism and the rhetoric of sensibility. Jun 29, 2020 after the election of lincoln in 1860 on the republican ticket, a number of pro slavery states seceded from the union, and the deepening secession crisis triggered the civil war.
1501 614 1349 1018 1553 1681 228 443 186 80 929 1310 519 1633 415 52 596 760 766 1686 1530 89 151 152 1245 1580 1581 214 881 530 1471 802 1367 1093